Contact Us:
626 Selby Ave, Suite A
Saint Paul, MN 55104
(651) 767-0298
Fax: (651) 221-9831

Previous: Vehicle Speed

SHARING THE ROAD: TRAFFIC AND ENFORCEMENT

Success Stories

• The Pedestrian Safety Project in Oakland, California, is hailed by the NHTSA as a national model. The program, which has strong community and police involvement, focuses on education, enforcement and infrastructure improvements. Hundreds of presentations and classes have been conducted to teach people pedestrian safety skills and safe driving techniques. The city targeted vulnerable populations including seniors (5). The city created a comprehensive 150-page pedestrian master plan and a Walk Oakland guide and map (6). It also provides mini-grants of $500 to $12,000 to communities. Police sting operations focusing on pedestrian safety have been widely used (7).

Santa Monica, California, conducted sting operations and saw auto-pedestrian collisions decrease by 23 percent (8).


The growth in traffic and increase in traffic violations is creating a hostile and dangerous environment for pedestrians and bicyclists in many urban areas, including the Twin Cities (1).

According to statistics from the National Highway Traffic Safety Administration, failure to yield contributed to 16 percent of fatal crashes in Minnesota, compared to 8 percent nationwide. Driver inattention contributed to 13 percent of the state’s fatal crashes, compared to 7 percent nationwide. Excessive and illegal speed is still the number one cause of vehicle crashes statewide (2).

In 1996, Minnesota strengthened the law requiring drivers to stop for pedestrians in marked or unmarked crosswalks. Minnesota now requires drivers to stop for pedestrians in or entering marked or unmarked crosswalks and prohibits vehicles from passing a vehicle that is stopped at a crosswalk (3). Anecdotal evidence suggests that majority of drivers do not stop for pedestrians. In 2001, in vehicle-pedestrian crashes for which a cause could be determined, 25 percent of drivers failed to yield the right-of-way to a pedestrian. Driver inattention or distraction was a factor in another 26 percent of crashes (4).

Minnesota targets only a small percentage of its state and federal traffic safety funding on bikes and pedestrians.

 

Recommendations

Increase traffic enforcement and utilize new enforcement strategies in order to make roads safer for drivers, transit users, pedestrians and bicyclists alike.

  • State and local governments should increase investment in traffic enforcement.
  • The state should permit local governments to use photo enforcement to ticket vehicles and cyclists who break traffic laws.
  • Local police should use new strategies that increase the effectiveness of enforcement efforts such as education/enforcement combinations and media campaigns.

Resources

 

Footnotes
1 Rosalind Bentley, “More refuse to Yield to Road Rules,” Minneapolis Star-Tribune, 31 Oct. 2002, accessed from www.startribune.com.
2 Laurie Blake, “Pay attention! Minnesota’s bad habits contribute to road deaths,” Minneapolis Star Tribune, 2 Feb. 2003, access from www.startribune.com.
3 Minnesota Statutes 2001, 169.21, Subd. 2.
4 Minnesota Crash Facts 2001, accessed on 10 October 2002 from www.dps.state.mn.us/OTS/crashdata/crash_facts.asp.
5 “Pedestrian Safety in California: Five Years of Progress and Pitfalls,” 5.
6 Laura Casey, “Pedestrian Safety in the City of Oakland,” Oakland Tribune, 22 Sept. 2002. Reprinted on City of Oakland’s website at http://www.oakland.com.
7 Tom Van de Mark, City of Oakland, phone interview with Sara Rohde, 19 Feb. 2003.
8 Toni Coleman, “It will take more than flags to protect pedestrians,” Saint Paul Pioneer Press, 7 Oct. 2002, accessed from www.twincities.com/mld/pioneerpress.